Olive
Birth order illustration
Birth Order
Edited by Judy Green
issue no. 2
Contents – june 2023
Editorial
Judy Green illustration
Letter from the Editor
I

’m usually rather good about not writing on topics with which I’m not well acquainted, being a firm believer in Alexander Pope’s comment that “A little knowledge is a dangerous thing.” Nonetheless, I have sallied forth with this issue organized around “birth order,” only to find out that birth order is much more complicated than I had thought. And I don’t just mean Alfred Adler’s concept of birth order, introduced into the psychological field in the early 20th century.

Because I love ambiguity (and that’s the subtitle for Olive), I thought I’d separate these words and see where I got when they were disassociated from each other. Of course, there are multiple definitions and categorizations for each one, so I decided to choose my favorite definition of “birth” and “order” from Merriam Webster, and see where I landed. See what you think.
Birth Order
Not All Created Equal:

Examining the Impact of Birth Order and Role Identity Among Descendant CEO Sons on Family Firm Performance
Authors: Mark T. Schenkel, Sean Sehyun Yoo, and Jaemin Kim
Research Applied précis prepared By Judy Green
Not All Created Equal
T

he authors of “Not All Created Equal” present a thoughtful and well-researched paper on the topic of birth order and role identity. Interestingly enough, their own section on “Limitations” highlights why this paper may have narrow applicability to practitioners dealing with clients outside of Korea while at the same time raising broad theoretical questions for family enterprise research on birth order, gender and primogeniture.

Using a sample of all Korea Exchange-listed, non-financial firms for which family data is available, the analysis is conducted on 1,776 firm-year observations from 1999-2002. Some of the more interesting findings of this study are as follows:

  • Founders, first son (FS) owners, and non-first son (NFS) owners appoint themselves CEO in 72%, 67% and 51% of the cases, respectively.
  • The prevalence of non-family CEOs is greater in NFS owner firms.
  • The prevalence of external influences in control and monitoring structures is higher for NFS controlled firms, than in founder or FS controlled firms.
  • NFS descendants are associated with higher family firm performance, perhaps because they are more inclined toward non-familial meritocracy.
Longevity
Longevity in the Family Business Context:

Implications for Leadership and Succession
Co-authored by Judy Green and Patricia Annino
Illustration of people walking across a rope between mountains
T

he year 2019 will mark the 50th anniversary of “walking on the moon”, a strange and foreign concept even today. Even stranger is the notion that life expectancy is now more or less casually discussed in terms of 100 years or slightly less.

Bypassing (at least for now) the enormous technological advances represented by 50+ years – we now think of vacationing on the moon, not just walking on it – this article pursues some of the implications of increased human longevity on the family enterprise field.

The Impact of Longevity on Family Business Leadership and Succession

With the increase of longevity comes a deeper awareness of the impact of competence. There are two sides to competence: sustained competence (when an older, competent family member, e.g., Queen Elizabeth, chooses not to leave or step down because she enjoys it and does not have to) and diminished competence (when the family business member has begun the long runway of diminishing competence, yet either is not aware of it or refuses to acknowledge it).

Death of the Old Broads
Death of the old broads
Death of the Old Broads
Before There Were Men
I

t is my fervent conviction that there existed in relatively recent generations some women who never, or rarely, compared themselves to men, did not worry about gender identity, and most asuuredly did not survive financially on inherited wealth. Either by accident (mostly unfortunate accident) or by design.

I readily admit that my sample is small! These are mostly women who crossed my path no later than 1990, after which it became impossible to ignore the various protests and movements that have taken place in the so-called “women’s movement.”

Here they are – a very regrettably finite list.

Friends of Judy
Driver’s License
Karen Shea on Driver’s Licenses
E

very few years each of us must make the trek to the DMV to get a new picture for our driver’s license. We all talk about it — the aggravation of the time it takes — the frustration with the sitting, trying to pose and hearing the click just before you are ready.

Then the wait until the woman calls your name and hands over the chit of plastic which ends up encasing your soul. Somehow this simple license-to-drive with photo — just a proof of who you are — becomes more. We stare at the image—I’m older looking… this one is better/worse than the last…
Friends of Judy
Words That Don’t Exist, But Should
Maquana – a Neologism by Mark Rubin
O

ver a recent family dinner, my daughter shared an unfortunate work situation which resulted in her feeling embarrassed in front of one of her colleagues. The reflexive response of “I’m so sorry that happened” didn’t seem to soothe our daughter who responded, “well, it wasn’t YOUR fault!”

Sometimes, words simply don’t exist to precisely describe an occurrence or express a specific feeling. The reality is that language can be inadequate. When the right word(s) don’t exist, perhaps it makes sense to create one to better express ourselves in more accurate and meaningful ways.
Olive
issue no. 2